One of the most common problems I see when teaching the LSAT is students struggling to find an assumption because they’ve already made it themselves.
The missing information feels so obvious that their brain supplies it automatically. By the time they finish reading, the argument already seems complete.
Here’s a simple example:
“The café downstairs sells sandwiches, so I’ll be able to buy lunch there at noon today.”
That probably sounds fine. It’s a café. It sells sandwiches. You want lunch. What’s the problem?
One assumption is that the café will be open at noon.
You may have already assumed that without giving it a second thought. Of course a café would be open at lunchtime. That’s when people buy lunch.
The statement only told you that it sells sandwiches. It never gave you its opening hours. If it’s closed at noon, the plan falls apart.
Now imagine an assumption question with an answer choice saying, “The café will be open at noon today.” A student might read that and think, “Well, yeah, obviously,” and keep looking for something more complicated.
That “obviously” is exactly how the assumption slipped past them.
This gets harder when a question discusses a familiar subject. You know how businesses usually operate, how people usually behave, or what normally happens in a particular situation. You quietly fill in those details while reading. Then you look for a gap in an argument you’ve already helped complete.
An assumption can be sensible, familiar, and likely to be true. Those qualities can make it especially easy to overlook. The fact that you would happily make it in everyday life doesn’t mean the argument established it.
You still get to use logic and the ordinary meanings of words. Keep track of the extra facts you find yourself supplying.
Something can feel obvious and still be exactly what the argument needs to assume.
