Every mistake I see when teaching the LSAT comes from one of three places: understanding the text, predicting the answer, or evaluating the choices.
Those are the only three places the process can break down. Whenever you get a question wrong, something went wrong in at least one of those stages.
Knowing which one is essential. Each stage involves a different skill, and figuring out where you’re struggling tells you what you need to work on.
1. You didn’t fully understand the text.
The first thing the LSAT asks you to do is read something and understand what it means. The language can be dense, the ideas can be unfamiliar, and the relationships between them can take time to work out.
Reading all the words doesn’t automatically give you that understanding. You need to be able to explain what you just read in your own words. In Logical Reasoning, that includes understanding what the author is claiming and the support they give. In Reading Comprehension, it includes understanding the passage’s ideas and how they fit together.
If you reach the questions with only a vague sense of what you read, you’re already trying to answer from an incomplete understanding. The work here is to slow down, rephrase difficult sentences, and connect each idea to what came before it until the text makes sense.
2. Your prediction was missing or inaccurate.
Once you understand the text, you need to work out what the answer to the question should say. That’s prediction: using your understanding of the text and the question to give yourself direction before you look at the choices.
For a flaw question, you identify the conclusion, the evidence, and the gap in the reasoning. For a question about a detail in an RC passage, you go back to the relevant part and work out what it establishes.
You can understand what you read and still struggle with this step. You might overlook the gap, draw an unsupported inference, or go straight to the answers without working out what you need. Then the choices start supplying competing ideas before you’ve developed your own.
The work here is to practice making that connection yourself: given what the text says and what the question asks, what would a correct answer need to say? Aim to predict its substance, or at least a clear direction, before opening the choices.
3. You had a sound prediction, but went wrong in the choices.
Sometimes you know what you’re looking for and then talk yourself into something else. You give a loosely related choice too much credit, overlook a word that changes its meaning, or reject the correct answer because it expresses your prediction differently.
Compare the choice you selected with the understanding you had going in. Identify exactly where its meaning departs from what the question needs. Also work out how the correct answer expresses the idea you were looking for. A sound prediction gives you a basis for being critical of the choices.
If none of the choices fits, check your understanding and prediction again.
When you review a missed question, trace those three stages. Did you understand the text? Did you work out what the answer needed to say? Did you accurately evaluate the choices? Finding where the process broke down tells you which skill needs your attention.
